Bird vs Twilio
将图标拖到圆点上。使用方向键移动已聚焦的图标。按 Escape 取消拖动。
深受工程和产品团队信赖, 助力其在全球范围内交付。
哪种验证流程适合你的应用?
Twilio Verify 适用的场景
Twilio's verification API supports voice calls and silent network authentication today alongside SMS, WhatsApp, and email. Bird's country routing plan currently delivers over SMS, WhatsApp, email, and Telegram while voice OTP rolls out, so teams relying on silent network checks or production voice OTP should plan for those channels before migrating.
Twilio Verify Services group sender names and code lengths per service, and each verification request accepts a custom template, locale, and pre-generated code. Audit which of those per-request overrides your app uses before moving to Bird's workspace-level sender and language settings.
Twilio's per-request risk check parameter toggles Fraud Guard and Geo Permissions on individual SMS attempts. If your signup flow relies on those carrier fraud rules, review how they map alongside Bird's resend cooldowns, recipient send caps, and country allowlists.
为什么选择 Bird Verify?
Bird selects the delivery channel from the recipient and destination country without requiring a parent Service SID. Each request can narrow or reorder the country plan, failed deliveries step forward automatically, and the same recipient phone number or email identifies code checks and fallback requests.
Bird's verification check response returns whether the code matched, the specific failure reason, and the number of attempts remaining so your login UI can tell the user how many tries are left.
Bird's hosted MCP server and CLI run the same verification workflow as the REST API, allowing engineers and AI agents to start verifications, check codes, and advance channels directly.
两者的 Verify API 对比如何?
Compare how each API handles verification requests, retry safety, attempt feedback, and channel fallback.
| 功能 | Bird | Twilio Verify | 谁更胜一筹? |
|---|---|---|---|
| 创建请求 | BirdSend a JSON request with a bearer key passing the recipient's email address, phone number, or both. | Twilio VerifySend a form-encoded request scoped under a Verify Service SID with the recipient and chosen channel. | 持平 |
| 安全重试 | BirdAn idempotency header prevents duplicate sends on network retries, while recipient resends reuse the active session and send a fresh passcode after the cooldown. | Twilio VerifyTwilio reuses the same passcode token across repeated requests during the validity window until verification succeeds. | 持平 |
| 失败验证告知您什么 | BirdReturns the verification outcome, failure reason, and remaining attempt count so your UI can distinguish a wrong code from a locked session. | Twilio VerifyVerification Check returns a status of pending, approved, or max-attempts-reached, and deletes the session once approved, expired, or locked. | Bird 胜出 |
| 验证码可送达的渠道 | BirdSMS, WhatsApp, email, and Telegram governed by the recipient's resolved country plan. | Twilio VerifySMS, email, WhatsApp, and voice calls, plus silent network authentication. | Twilio Verify 胜出 |
| 按请求配置 | BirdOverride code length, allowed channels, and message language per request while inheriting sender identities from your workspace. | Twilio VerifySelect a Verify Service and pass per-request options for custom templates, locales, custom passcodes, and friendly names. | Twilio Verify 胜出 |
| 托管 MCP 服务器 | BirdAn authenticated hosted MCP server and the Bird CLI run verification creation, code checks, and channel fallback. | Twilio VerifyTwilio's hosted docs MCP searches documentation without calling live APIs, while Twilio Labs' local MCP server and the Twilio CLI execute API requests. | Bird 胜出 |
| 投递事件 | BirdWorkspace webhooks stream session and delivery attempt events signed with Standard Webhooks. | Twilio VerifyVerify Events (Pilot) streams verification and message status for SMS, WhatsApp, RCS, and Voice to a webhook or Amazon Kinesis. | 持平 |
| 渠道降级 | BirdFailed deliveries advance the country plan automatically, and the next-channel operation lets your app switch channels on request while keeping earlier codes valid. | Twilio VerifyAutomatic SMS Fallback attempts silent network authentication and falls back to SMS in Pilot. | 持平 |
谁推进回退,哪个验证码仍然有效?
Bird steps forward to the next channel in the recipient's country plan when a delivery fails. Your application can also call the next-channel endpoint when a user clicks to receive their code another way. Each step advances one channel and sends a fresh passcode, while earlier passcodes in that session remain valid until expiration.
In Bird, your app starts a verification with the user's contact details, follows the resolved country plan through automatic or user-requested channel advancement, and checks the code against that same recipient.
In Twilio, automatic channel selection is scoped to silent network authentication falling back to SMS in Pilot, and Twilio's passcode token remains unchanged across retries during the validity window.
校验后你的应用应存储什么?
Persist the verified authentication state in your database as soon as the check succeeds. Bird matches the check by the recipient set passed on creation, and returns a structured failure reason with remaining attempts when a user enters the wrong code. Once a session completes or expires, subsequent checks return a not-found response.
Twilio's Verification Check also matches by recipient or Verification SID under the parent Service SID, and deletes the verification record once approved, expired, or locked out.
迁移时需要保留哪些滥用控制?
Bird's abuse guardrails enforce a resend cooldown, per-recipient send limits, and maximum check attempts per session. Requesting the next backup channel bypasses the resend timer so users are not stuck waiting, bounded by the channels enabled in your country plan.
Twilio's SMS risk check setting controls Fraud Guard and Geo Permissions per attempt. Review how your signup flow uses those carrier fraud rules alongside Bird's country allowlists and send caps before cutting over traffic.
验证和发送如何计费?
There's no plan, seat, or platform fee for Bird Verify. Each delivery is charged at that channel's rate for the destination. A resend, or a fallback that moves delivery to a second channel, is a new send and a new charge.
A verdict compares only published delivery rates with the same channel, destination, currency, billing unit and sender type. Per-success verification fees and per-send charges are Not comparable: your own sends and successful checks determine usage.
Pricing verdict: Not comparable
| 已发布项目 | Twilio Verify | Bird 计费政策 |
|---|---|---|
| Base pricing Per successful verification | $0.05 USD Per successful verification plus standard channel fees. as published | There's no plan, seat, or platform fee for Bird Verify. 通道发送单独计费。请查看以下实时通道费率。 |
| SMS (US) Per SMS Destination: US | $0.0083 USD Per SMS (US). The successful-verification fee is charged separately. as published | There's no plan, seat, or platform fee for Bird Verify. 通道发送单独计费。请查看以下实时通道费率。 |
| WhatsApp (US) Per authentication template message Destination: US | $0.0034 USD Per authentication template message (US). The successful-verification fee is charged separately. as published | There's no plan, seat, or platform fee for Bird Verify. 通道发送单独计费。请查看以下实时通道费率。 |
| Voice Per successful verification | $0.05 USD Per successful verification. Voice channel pricing applies separately. as published | There's no plan, seat, or platform fee for Bird Verify. 通道发送单独计费。请查看以下实时通道费率。 This method is outside Bird’s documented Verify channel plan. |
| Email Per successful verification | $0.05 USD Per successful verification. Email channel pricing applies separately. as published | There's no plan, seat, or platform fee for Bird Verify. 通道发送单独计费。请查看以下实时通道费率。 |
| Silent Network Auth Per successful verification | $0.05 USD Per successful verification plus per-country channel fee. as published | There's no plan, seat, or platform fee for Bird Verify. 通道发送单独计费。请查看以下实时通道费率。 This method is outside Bird’s documented Verify channel plan. |
| Push Per approved or denied request | Push channel fee is included in the verification fee. It’s charged when a request is approved or denied. as published | There's no plan, seat, or platform fee for Bird Verify. 通道发送单独计费。请查看以下实时通道费率。 This method is outside Bird’s documented Verify channel plan. |
| TOTP Per approved request | TOTP channel fee is included in the verification fee. It’s charged when a request is approved. as published | There's no plan, seat, or platform fee for Bird Verify. 通道发送单独计费。请查看以下实时通道费率。 This method is outside Bird’s documented Verify channel plan. |
| Volume pricing Custom volume | Contact sales Contact sales for volume-based discounts. as published | There's no plan, seat, or platform fee for Bird Verify. 通道发送单独计费。请查看以下实时通道费率。 |
Bird 已发布的 SMS 通道费率
Bird's SMS catalogue rates are shown by sender type, per message segment. Carrier fees and sender costs may apply separately. These channel rates are not a total verification quote. SMS pricing; carrier fees.
| 目的地 | 发送方类型 | 每个 SMS 分段 |
|---|---|---|
| US | long_code | EUR 0.003 |
| US | long_code | USD 0.0035 |
| US | toll_free | EUR 0.003 |
| US | toll_free | USD 0.0035 |
| US | short_code | EUR 0.006 |
| US | short_code | USD 0.007 |
Bird email pricing and Bird WhatsApp pricing publish the other delivery channels.
如何发起一次验证?
Twilio's Node SDK creates a verification under a Verify Service SID. Bird's create endpoint takes the recipient directly and accepts an idempotency key for safe network retries.
import twilio from "twilio";
const client = twilio(process.env.TWILIO_ACCOUNT_SID!, process.env.TWILIO_AUTH_TOKEN!);
try {
const verification = await client.verify.v2
.services(process.env.TWILIO_VERIFY_SERVICE_SID!)
.verifications.create({
to: "+15551234567",
channel: "sms",
});
console.log(verification.sid, verification.status);
} catch (err) {
console.error(err);
}
import { BirdClient } from "@messagebird/sdk";
const bird = new BirdClient({ apiKey: process.env.BIRD_API_KEY! });
const { data, error } = await bird.verify.verifications
.create(
{
to: { phone_number: "+15551234567" },
options: { code_length: 6, channels: ["sms"] },
},
)
.safe();
if (error) console.error(error.message);
else console.log(data.id, data.status);
切换前需要做哪些调整?
Audit each Twilio Verify Service's enabled channels, custom templates, Fraud Guard rules, and fallback paths. Follow the Twilio migration guide to map recipient addressing and check responses, and plan an alternative if your app depends on voice calls, silent network authentication, or custom passcode strings.
Send new verification requests through Bird while routing in-flight code checks to Twilio until existing sessions expire. Persist verified outcomes in your database, test resend cooldowns and next-channel fallbacks, and review Bird's sender identities and translated messages before full cutover.
选择前应检查哪些事项?
Bird 能替代 Twilio Verify 用于 SMS 和邮件验证吗?
Does a second request generate a different passcode?
能否迁移所有 Twilio 模板和语言区域设置?
Does a 404 response mean the user entered the wrong code?
下一步
Start with the field-by-field migration guide, or explore Verify channels and pricing.
- 从 Twilio 迁移 VerifyMap Twilio Verify Services, verification requests, and code checks onto Bird with clear guidance on settings that differ.
- Bird 与 Prelude 的 Verify 对比Compare recipient-addressed verification, fraud risk verdicts, and multi-channel fallback against Prelude.
- 验证方案对比Compare OTP delivery, retry safety, and verification workflows across providers.
- 验证定价Review how channel sends and resends are billed across destination countries.
- 通道编排Configure per-country channel order and automatic fallback across SMS, WhatsApp, email, and Telegram.
- Bird 与 AI 智能体Run verification checks, inspect delivery logs, and manage configuration through the hosted MCP server and Bird CLI.
将验证融入你的产品。
与我们的团队沟通你的渠道、验证流程和预期流量。